Wednesday, February 23, 2011
Sunday, February 20, 2011
Brief Update
So it’s been awhile since I updated…partially due to lack of time and partially due to my grim internet situation. For some reason, my internet card expired, so I don’t have wifi access, which makes it pretty difficult to update my blog. I’m currently on one of the university computers with a very low speed internet connection.
A few small updates:
- We presented a semi-finished project to Chharanagar on Saturday, which went pretty well. We still have a week to finish up work on it based on the response we got at the presentation. We followed the long morning up with a nice siesta and dinner at a fantastic traditional restaurant called Rajwadu. The entire restaurant is outside, beautifully landscaped, with short tables and rugs to sit on the floor. There were also several entertainment stations around the place with magicians, dancers, and musicians. Many of the Chharas joined us for dinner, so it was fun to hang out with them and not have to worry about school related stuff.
- We spent the majority of last week mapping out Chharanagar. We started with a google earth image that Tad traced in Rhino, which turned out to be fairly inaccurate due to the pixilated image and rapid building changes that have occurred since the image was taken. We then went through the entire community and manually checked all buildings, pathways, trees and temples. After mapping each neighborhood within Chharanagar, we compiled the results, made all of the edits in Illustrator and produced a final map. The Chharas were ecstatic and definitely appreciated our work. As soon as I have internet again on my laptop I can upload the image.
- There are mice in our hotel. Tad saw one run into my room when we were talking outside. We told the hotel guys, and they pretended to care for a few minutes like it was something unusual. The next day I found mouse poop on my bed. Three days later I realized I was in India for the thousandth time and decided that things would be much easier if I chose to just not care about it. So far that’s working out for me…
- I’m doing much better with the food. I might even dare to say that it’s growing on me…or even…gasp…that I might miss some of it once we leave India.
- Yesterday we went back to wonderful Khadia and visited the Mehtas. It was great to see them, and great to be back on the other side of the river. We did a good deal of last minute India shopping and visited some of the Sunday markets for probably the last time.
- We’re in Ahmedabad for about another week. We then go to Delhi for a few days, then it’s off to Kathmandu. I’m debating whether I should make the trip to Agra to see the Taj Mahal. I suppose it depends on what the alternative for the day is. Nihal talked about the possibility of going to New Delhi that day instead, which at this point in time sounds more appealing than Taj Mahal. I guess we’ll see.
- Today we’re going to see a Cricket World Cup match! It’s Australia vs. Zimbabwe, which is supposedly going to be a blow out. The match is also supposed to last eight hours. I think it’s pretty safe to say that I will definitely not be staying for the entire game.
Thursday, February 17, 2011
Laundry drying in Chharanagar |
My experience in India could best be defined as the exhausting, though fascinating tension between acceptance and rejection, referring to both my acceptance and rejection of this place and it’s culture, as well as its acceptance and rejection of me. Inspiring and discouraging experiences are so intertwined that I am pulled in so many directions, seeking a balance that has yet to be achieved. I may never get to experience this balance in my time here, as it is running short, and I imagine that I will leave with a feeling of near satisfaction.
I got a goat! |
I feel like every time you start to get high on India, it figures you out and smacks you in the face again. From the food and living accommodations to the social interactions and transportation methods, as soon as I get used to it, it all screws me over again. This may be also partially…I mean 100%...related to our studio project and the instruction we’re receiving. Maybe at the end, it will all work out fine; there have just been more than a few frustrations along the way. I think my snapping point, which occurred about a week ago, happened on the day of my last entry, after returning from Mumbai. Rickshaw drivers ripped me off three times in one day, I was hit by a studio project that I mentally checked out of during Mumbai, some classic Indian food wreaked havoc on my stomach, and just as I arrive back at the hotel and sit down to use the bathroom, I see a cockroach scurry across the washroom door. I think the last bit of patience I had for this place was squashed along with the cockroach on the door.
Atish, Patrick, Tad, and Joy mapping in Chharanagar |
I know this sounds pretty dismal, but I was definitely at my India low at this point. Luckily after a few nights of sleep though, which facilitated the recovery from my cold (which is finally gone!), I got back up, and began to appreciate this place again. Most of our energy, since the return from Mumbai, has been concentrated on our work in Chharanagar. In the past week, we’ve been working on creating an accurate map of the community. Tad originally traced the outline of the buildings from the very pixilated Google Earth image, but due to pixilation, as well as rapid community change, it turned out to be relatively inaccurate, and we realized it was necessary to manually edit the map by walking through the entire community, editing building shapes, hidden alleys and pathways, and open spaces. The project required four full afternoons of three to four people mapping the community’s complexities and attempting to understand the haphazard development that comprises its center. Rinkcu and Joy from the Budhan Theatre helped us everyday, along with Atish and Hitesh.
MONKEYS!! |
Yesterday I had a seriously good animal day. As I’m sure you’ve noticed already, I’m pretty obsessed with all the dogs and any other animals that wander around the streets here. Chharanagar also has an overabundance of goats, which supposedly are kept as pets. While Tad was figuring out where we were on the map, I spent a good chunk of time trying to chase down the goats and pet them. Finally one of the kids caught a baby for me so I got to hold it! I also got to hold a tiny puppy…from one of the few pet dogs that exist in India. In addition to the dogs, goats, cows, camels, and elephants, there are also monkeys that roam the streets and swing on the tops of buildings. I usually see them only in passing on a rickshaw or something, so I haven’t had an opportunity to photograph them, but yesterday a whole group of them ran out in front of us in Chharanagar, and I finally got to take some pictures of the fierce looking creatures.
Young girl in Chharanagar |
Today we finished the mapping, which was definitely a relief, though tomorrow we still have to edit all of the line work on the computer. On Saturday, we present to Chharanagar all that we have done so far. I think it will consist of a combination of what we’ve learned/our experiences, the map we’ve produced, and the plan/proposal for community development/empowerment, particularly regarding the town planning scheme that the government may potentially push to implement, which would destroy many homes and carelessly rework and layout a new community, with no input from the actual community. We’re also hoping to get some feedback from the community so that we can improve our recommendations in the following week we’ll have before we leave.
Thursday, February 10, 2011
Two days in Mumbai
To begin, today I definitely do not possess the amount of patience and tolerance it takes to function in Indian society, so this entry might be somewhat negative, but for the most part, I’ll try to keep it fairly neutral.
On Sunday, we packed up from the Heritage House, and headed to Baroda. Along the way, we stopped at Amul, a large dairy corporation that collects milk from individual farmers, then processes and sells the products. It was pretty interesting, unfortunately though, we weren’t allowed to take photos. I did have some tasty ice cream though. Ice cream is definitely something that India did get right. After a few more stops and a few more hours of traveling, we met Dr. Ganesh Devy, the man who inspired the library and Budhan Theatre at Chharanagar, for dinner. It was just one of those times that I really, really didn’t want to do Indian food, but we had a pretty awesome Indian feast in the style of a sort of buffet that comes to you. Dr. Ganesh was very interesting, though it was difficult to hear him, as he was sitting at the other table.
The next day, we headed to a tribal school, though I’m not really sure what the location was. We toured the school, spoke with some of the directors, and hiked up a nearby mountain. On the side of the mountain, we were able to see 12,000-year-old cave paintings, which was really neat. Nihal kind of made it sound like we’d be climbing to the top of the mountain, though the cave was only about 25% of the way up. After this we headed back to the hotel, packed up, showered, and hit the Baroda train station to catch our midnight train to Mumbai. As I said earlier, it really wasn’t too bad of an experience, despite my difficulty sleeping on the train. I think this may have partially been to do my reading of an article in the newspaper that morning that involved a Mumbai-bound train derailing…
Probably the strangest experience we had with the whole train situation happened before we were even on board. While Tad and I were waiting, three dogs ran up and down the platform, playing and occasionally barking. All of a sudden a man who was either crazy or drunk (though I’m not sure how this would be the case, as Gujarat is dry) started harassing the dogs and one of them went after him, attacking his arm. Luckily though the man had a coat on and was probably unharmed by the dog. About 15 minutes later, the man went after the dogs again. He approached them, yelling and shaking his hand at them. All three were growling, and as the man got close, the same dog sprang forward and bit the man’s hand, which started gushing blood. I’m not sure what the guy’s deal was, but he definitely had it coming to him by the way he approached the dogs. The dogs showed no aggression to anyone else on the platform and were even affectionate to some of the station personnel. Only in India.
We arrived in Mumbai around 7 in the morning, checked in at the hotel, did some laundry, had a rest, then finally went out to explore the city. We began with lunch and a beer, then did a ton of walking, saw the Gateway to India, and the Taj Mahal Hotel. While we were at the gateway monument, Tad and I had Grace take a picture of us. While we were posing, we were surrounded by Indian people that tried to pose in the picture with us. What?! It was a very bizarre experience. Finally though, we were able to get a decent photo. That night we went to a few bars, found a place that actually serves beef, and then went back to the hotel around midnight after a full day and hectic night before.
The following day, which was yesterday, Tad and I broke off from the rest of the group and went to see Chowpatti Beach and the hanging garden, known as Ferozeshah Mehta Gardens. We got to see the city from the oasis-like large hill that sits inside of the city. We had lunch at a diner-type place (though it was veg). We both ordered “Cheese Burgers.” Ha. They tasted like a veggie egg roll in burger form, which really wasn’t that horrible, just not quite what we were hoping for. The menus looked like they had been constructed by google searching ‘burger’ and ‘sandwich;’ there were, very clearly, an image of thick, beef hamburger and a wonderful looking turkey sandwich. I would be surprised, but oh wait, I’m in India. However though, they did have beer, and they did have diet coke, so Tad and I were still pretty satisfied.
To conclude the trip, we ended the night with that awful restaurant I mention previously, which still makes me a little nauseous to think about. After that, we packed up, slept for a couple hours, then took a taxi to the airport for the 6:25 flight that lasted less than an hour. Now we’re back here in wonderful Ahmedabad in a new hotel that I would describe as relatively okay by Indian standards. Now it’s only two people to a room, plus there are western toilets, toilet paper, and hot showers, so I guess I can’t really complain too much. But there’s no internet and it’s located right next to a large road in the new city that makes the place endlessly loud. Did I mention that I’m in India?
I’m not totally fed up with this place, it’s more that I’ve been sick with a bad cold for a week and a half and am starting to wonder if the horrible air quality here is what is keeping me from getting better. I also had to wake up at 3:20 this morning to catch a 6:25 flight back to Ahmedabad from Mumbai, and despite the nap I took at the new hotel we’re staying at now, I’m still exhausted. Also, I’m starting to stress out about our studio project here; we’ve got about nine days to finish, and (1) I think we need more research and (2) I have no idea what my role in this project should be. Also, I think my tolerance for Indian food disintegrated overnight. I’m tired of having an upset stomach every other day! Last night we went to a questionable restaurant in Mumbai, and Tad’s pretty sure he ate an eyeball in his mutton. Following dinner, we also saw large cockroaches and rats the size of guinea pigs in the street outside the restaurant. This combo definitely did not help my already churning stomach. Ok I’m done complaining now.
On a much more positive note, I’ve gotten to see some awesome things in the past few days. Unfortunately on Saturday night, we had to say goodbye to the wonderful Mehta family, who we have been staying with since our arrival in India. We had a bit of a party that night with some singing and dancing. It was definitely sad to say goodbye to the old city, even though it’s still only a rickshaw ride away. Basically, compared to the old city, the new city sucks…though that’s just my opinion. Everything is much more spread out, somewhat more expensive, and much less interesting.
Fancy Indian dinner |
12,000-year-old cave paintings |
Tad and I on the side of the mountain |
Next to the Gateway to India, Mumbai |
I'd say we were both pretty happy campers |
The following day, which was yesterday, Tad and I broke off from the rest of the group and went to see Chowpatti Beach and the hanging garden, known as Ferozeshah Mehta Gardens. We got to see the city from the oasis-like large hill that sits inside of the city. We had lunch at a diner-type place (though it was veg). We both ordered “Cheese Burgers.” Ha. They tasted like a veggie egg roll in burger form, which really wasn’t that horrible, just not quite what we were hoping for. The menus looked like they had been constructed by google searching ‘burger’ and ‘sandwich;’ there were, very clearly, an image of thick, beef hamburger and a wonderful looking turkey sandwich. I would be surprised, but oh wait, I’m in India. However though, they did have beer, and they did have diet coke, so Tad and I were still pretty satisfied.
At the hanging garden in Mumbai |
Hanging gardens |
Ornate building close to our hotel |
One more note on Mumbai. The colonialism here was overly evident. The city felt so European, I almost questioned whether I was still in India or not. It was such an odd and unique combination, though I still think it worked quite well, at least in the area that we were in. The truth is that we only were able to see a fraction of the city. It’s such a massive place with so many people (approximately 15 million) that it’s nearly impossible to develop a comprehensive understanding of the entire place, especially since we were only there for two days.
Monday, February 7, 2011
Mini Update
Just a mini update as I think my internet at the hotel is about to expire. We arrived in Mumbai this morning around 7 after taking the midnight train from Baroda. It was a bit of an interesting experience, though not too bad. Later I'll be able to put up a picture I took in the cabin. Unfortunately I didn't get to sleep much, but it was nice to have bunks. Not sure what today holds...everyone is currently recuperating from the train ride and freshening up. I will leave you with this though...the cutest puppies ever from the heritage walk in Ahmedabad.
Saturday, February 5, 2011
The past few days have been a bit weird, but then again I'm speaking as if I have some idea of "normal" here in India.
The Land Use Plan for Auroville |
On Monday I attended a lecture by about the utopian society know as Auroville. The talk was given by Lalit Kishor Bhati, a planner-architect that lives within the community. Located near the Southern tip of India, this sustainable, idealistic community focuses on integrated planning and holistic development. A particular emphasis is placed on the unity of humanity, importance of sustainability, and education as the center of development. I found the idea of this society fascinating, though I'm not sure I'd want to live there for more than a year...I definitely would like to visit though. Unfortunately it's extremely far away from our itinerary locations, so I don't think I'll get to visit. If you're interested, here's more information: http://www.auroville.org/.
Non-violence through dance |
After the Auroville lecture, I spent the day in Chharanagar with the "Social Infrastructure" group, doing several interviews, which were fairly informative and rather successful. That night, we attended a play at Darpan Theatre by Mallika Sarabhai (http://darpanaacademy.blogspot.com/). The focus of the performance was "Non-violence through art/dance." Although I had no idea what to expect, I was impressed by the concise, yet powerful message that was sent through a series of unique, yet connected stories of how different individuals have protested injustice and violence. We also saw some of the Budhan Theatre guys at the performance, which was exciting, since we don't usually see them outside of Chharanagar.
Puppy outside of Vidyapith |
On Wednesday, we went to Gujarat Vidyapith University (I believe a school that Gandhi started) to talk to some people who study different tribes in India. It was somewhat successful, but fairly time intensive for the amount of information I actually got out of it. This might be lame, but I think the picture of this puppy might be the best thing I got out of the visit. After the discussion and museum tour, the eight of us who are going to Mumbai next week went to purchase tickets at the train station, which was an interesting experience; I probably should have taken a photo of the experience. All I'll say for now though is, the 7 hour train ride from Baroda to Mumbai is going to be interesting.
Vendor that Tad and I ate at last night in Manek Chok |
I talked previously about Khadia and the pols after going on the Heritage Walk. Unfortunately today is our last day in Khadia and the Old City, which I'm pretty bummed about. After we return from Mumbai, we'll be staying at a hotel in the New City. The plus is that we'll be much closer to CEPT, but I'm really going to miss the density of the Old City and the availability of shops and street vendors around every corner. I'm also going to miss the Mehta family; they've been so welcoming, hospitable, and helpful to us as we're discovering this part of India. This morning was the last yoga session on the roof, which is a little more sad now than it was at 7:30 this morning.
I think that most Westerners would probably find a "McVeggie" sign that says 'I bet you can't resist me' at least mildly humorous. |
I'm not sure if I've mentioned the Indian-ized McDonald's that they have here, but it's definitely something I have to touch on. Because no one eats beef here, there are obviously no hamburgers here, which entirely redefines most McDonald's experiences. So far from what I've had, the fries and the McChicken are about the same; I can't really speak for the rest of the menu. I suppose the ice cream is about the same as well. Last night Tad and I had a wonderful new ice cream experience at a street vendor. It's called Kulfi, which is essentially a dense, round, slightly salted ice cream. It was, of course, wonderful!
Kulfi, my new favorite! |
So as we head out tomorrow, I feel like I'm tossing out most of the adjustments that I've just accomplished, which is kind of a bummer, but I'm excited to see more new things. Plus, we'll be coming back to Ahmedabad for a few weeks again after this minor field trip, before we head to Nepal.
Wednesday, February 2, 2011
A day of Corb & Kahn
Mill Association building grounds |
On Tad's birthday, last Thursday, we went to go see Le Corbusier's Mill Association building. I'm not a huge Corbusier fan, but I really did enjoy the building. We also found out at the end that we weren't supposed to be taking pictures...whoops.
Louis Kahn's IIM |
"Portobello Fajitas" |
A few short notes on a few things I’ve been thinking about
Common room in the Heritage House
The Translators: Observations on India and Haiti
The Theatre guys helping Tad map out the community |
Tad's Birthday at Chharanagar |
I’ve noticed, both in my experiences in India and Haiti, that while you are trying to speak to others, be it the people of the village in Haiti or the Chharas in India, a relationship is developed not necessarily with the people you are trying to communicate with, but rather the people that you communicate through. The guys at the Budhan Theatre, who are all about our age, have been great with helping us to get to know the community better and understand the way it works. Over the past few weeks though, we’ve become friends with them, similarly as we did the translators in Haiti, and I think that establishing this friendship is an interesting gateway to understanding the culture of a people and a place. They even threw Tad a birthday party last Thursday and gave him a cake. It was so nice!
No One Killed Jessica
So Tad and I saw our first Indian movie a few days ago! About 30% of it was in English, the other 70% in Hindi. For the most part, we could follow what was going on (it was a murder case, inspired by a true story). For some reason, they liked to start a whole long narrative in English, act like they had something really important to say, then break into Hindi…which obviously just left us hanging, but it was still enjoyable. Tickets were only Rps. 100, which is slightly over $2. It was kind of strange though, they had assigned seats in the theatre, like we were going to a play or something. Overall though, it was a good time!
Here's the trailer: No One Killed Jessica Trailer
The dog we refer to as "Scooby's Indian Nephew" finishing off some lunch and chai at the CEPT canteen |
Chai and Food
I believe that earlier in my blog I expressed my skepticism of the ever popular “chai” that seems to be essential at any conversation, social gathering, or break. Well it didn’t take too long to convince me of it, and now I’m more or less obsessed. I usually end up having about three cups a day (it’s only about Rps. 5 for cup! Which roughly is $0.11!). I even bought my own chai cup from the canteen at CEPT :) I’ve also been adjusting to the food rather well, figuring out what I like and what my stomach can handle.
Dogs on Mopeds !!
So there are dogs everywhere in the city. Most of them are pretty mangy, covered in fleas, and entirely indifferent to people unless they have food. I love dogs, so naturally I tend to pay attention to them wherever we’re at. My most recent fascination though has been dogs on mopeds! I saw several on the heritage walk, and I’m keeping my eye out for more!
Puppy 1 |
Puppy 2 |
Puppy 4 |
Puppy 5...this one kind of looks like he's doing yoga...haha |
Who doesn't love a dog on a moped?
Tuesday, February 1, 2011
Could I actually be somewhat adjusted?
So it’s been awhile since I’ve had time to update, which is not because I have nothing to say…I have TONS of things to write about, just very little time. I think tonight though I might lose a little sleep to catch up on a few things that I’ve been thinking about recently.
The normal lunch at the CEPT canteen: dal, rice & roti |
The first is adjustment. Over the past few days, I’ve moved from the semi-panicked, partially paranoid, and doubtful mindset, that at least for me, was unavoidable when coming to India. This place requires a massive amount of patience and flexibility…two things that I definitely don’t do well with. Add in the most unfamiliar food I’ve even been exposed to, bathroom facilities that continue to perplex me, close quarters with a study group I’ve only recently come to know, and the most uniquely peculiar phenomenon that is the Indian lifestyle and mindset, and I was essentially completely lost and 100% disoriented upon arrival.
Laudry drying in the pols |
Even after the first and second weeks when I felt like I had seen and experienced so much, I still didn’t know any sort of comfort in this place, and I certainly had no desire or intention to settle into the way things are here as if I were to try and live as the Indians do. After the third week though, heading into the fourth, I have begun to develop an immense appreciation for this place, both Ahmedabad (the city we’re staying in…of 6 million + people) and Khadia (the district where we’re staying, part of the old city, very dense, compact development centered around ‘Pols’, which are essentially courtyards and cul-de-sacs around tiny roads and pathways).
I’m not sure how I came to achieve, or at least how I started to achieve, this adjustment, but I have a few ideas. One is that as I begin to see other parts of the city and state, such as the new city area on the other side of the river in Ahmedabad and Gandhinagar still in Gujarat (the state), I’m beginning to appreciate what is here is Khadia. There is a constant vitality here that is evident by the sheer volume of people and the intensely packed sidewalks full of people eating, selling, buying, bargaining, sleeping, and talking, and the constant bustle and rush of the two wheelers and rickshaws that nearly brush your shoulder as they seemingly carelessly fly past.
Planned residential area in Gandhinagar, built around 1970 |
The new city, though it is still full of life and activity, has a bit of a Western taste and a lower density of development that seems far less profound than the delightfully crowded and congested old city and Khadia. Similarly, a trip to Gandhinagar, a new city (last 50 years) that was planned specifically to be the capitol of Gujarat, was mildly disappointing. A general disconnect was felt between different parts of the city, the highway felt so Western that I almost wondered if I was in Illinois, and the scattered density across the large space felt more like a suburb that the state capitol. So in short, the density and vitality of Khadia is invigorating, though at times somewhat exhausting, and seeing these other places is allowing me to appreciate the place where I am now.
Homes on the heritage walk |
Also, on Monday we went on a “Heritage Walk” of the old city in Ahmedabad, which was actually partially in Khadia. A slideshow was shown previous to the two and a half hour walk that described the city’s development over time and laid out the organization and connectivity within the city. For the first time after three weeks, I actually had some sense of orientation to something other than the river. The walk in general was fantastic and definitely gave me a sense of understanding of this place that I was lacking prior to the tour.
Some of the great Budhan guys, Tad, Wenya, and myself |
Another reason that I think I’m becoming more comfortable and feeling somewhat more adjusted is that we’re actually getting to know people now. We’re becoming good friends with the translators/Budhan theatre guys in Chharanagar, as they are mostly our age and have many common interests. There is also such a genuine curiosity between those guys and our group that we have much to discuss, ask, and learn about.
Me with some of the kids in Chharanagar |
So as I pass this three-week mark, I pass my max travel time in the past. I was in Europe for three weeks slightly over six years ago, but even then I moved from place to place every few days. From my experience here, I’m learning the incredible value of “temporarily settling down” somewhere. There are many things I still don’t understand about Ahmedabad and Khadia, and most of them I won’t even come to know. I will never entirely understand this place; I doubt anyone who even lives here can. But there is no way that I can even have a slight idea what life is like here without spending at least this amount of time here. Not to say that three weeks can give me a holistic understanding necessarily, but it can give me more from a place and a travel experience than I’ve ever had before.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)